Punching A Dog is NOT Training, It’s Animal Abuse


Punching a dog repeatedly to establish dominance is animal abuse, period. That’s true, even if a police dog handler is training a police dog as much as it is true for anyone training a pet dog.

In Vacaville, CA (midway between San Francisco and Sacramento) this police officer was caught on video “correcting” his dog.

To be clear, this isn’t training, it’s abuse. It’s hard to believe that any professional trainer still supports the mistaken notion punching a dog has any place whatsoever in training. And I suggest this is even more true for police dogs, whom an officer is required to develop a trusting relationship, which may make the difference between life and death.

Apparently, the explanation here for this action is that the dog had tried to bite the handler.  It’s possible that this individual dog just isn’t the best choice for this job. But even more likely, what is known is that aggression begets fear and mistrust which leads to further aggression.

Force or punishment does work to instantly stop a behavior. But there’s fall out as a result, aside from welfare concerns

I recall about a decade or 15 years ago or more when legendary veterinary behaviorist Dr. Karen Overall, began to work with law enforcement and the U.S. military, to shift to positive reinforcement training. Following in her pioneering efforts other trainers have done the same, and many police departments and even the U.S. military now utilyze positive reinforcement training. Positive reinforcement training isn’t only a humane alternative, it is also FAR more effective.

The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior has authored a position statement, debunking the myth that there is any need for dominance training.  This position paper was authored just a few years ago, based on peer-reviewed published papers. Today, there’s even more evidence consistent to support the advantages of learning more effectively using positive reinforcement.

For me, the most compelling study I’ve seen is when veterinary behaviorist Dr. Theresa DePorter, based in Bloomfield Hills, MI, looked at a local dog trainer who used aversive training methods in his puppy classes. After one year, 38 percent of the puppy class grads were re-homed, surrendered or euthanized. It gets worse, after two years, 60 percent of dogs were re-homed, surrendered or euthanized.

Puppy classes should be fun, but so should training even for military working dogs

DePorter then convinced that same trainer to offer positive reinforcement classes, and instructed him on how to do so. The five weekly in-hospital puppy socialization classes were for pups ages seven to 12 weeks. This wasn’t a typical tiny study of a pawful of dogs; she followed 519 puppies for a year.  And one year later, 94 percent of dogs remained in homes, compared to aversive training which over a third of puppies re-homed, surrendered or euthanized a year later.

The better the relationship a military working dog has with the handler, the greater the odds they both live. studies have analyzed training methods used on military working dogs (MWD). A 2008  survey of 303 Belgian MWD handlers revealed the use of harsh training methods were not as effective as positive reinforcement, and may even present a welfare issues. Pulling on the leash and hanging dogs by their collars were the most commonly used aversive stimuli. The team’s performance was influenced by the training method and by the dogs’ concentration: (1) low-performance dogs received more aversive stimuli than high-performance dogs; (2) dog’s distraction influenced the performance; distracted dogs performed less well. And positive reinforcement seemed to positively impact the relationship and the bond with the handler.

Laura Monaco Torelli using positive reinforcement

2020 was a good for year dog training because Petco made a huge statement by stopping the sales of shock or e-collars. Karen Pryor Certified faculty member and dog trainer Laura Monaco Torelli of Animal Behavior Training Concepts explains HERE on my WGN Radio Steve Dale’s Pet World radio show that she agrees. Monaco Torelli talks about how dogs trained with aversive methods often shut down, taking the “joy” out of their life. However, more often, the fall out causes all sorts of issues which she explains. When shock collars are used, dogs are more hesitant to offer behaviors – apparently concerned about what might happen. I suggest that punching a dog is even worse.

Science matters a great deal, but how about what is simply a ‘gut feeling?’ How can watching this video of the officer repeatedly punching his dog be right? I suggest this police department requires a new dog trainer or a veterinary behaviorist if the current trainer is even remotely accepting of these actions.

Three factual statements:

  1. When training (particularly law enforcement dogs), there is a need to communicate from one end of the leash to the other, and develop trust. The best way to do this is to use positive reinforcement, and to make training interesting and even fun.
  2. There is need for structure and for handlers to teach. However, there is NEVER a need to dominate dogs. There’s no point to this. The notion of dominance dates back to the 1950’s and was associated initially with wolf behavior. That association was mistaken in the first place (today wolf pack behavior is better understood), and in the second place dogs are decidedly not wolves.
  3. Forcing a dog down to the ground, and then repeatedly punching the dog is animal abuse. Period.

I am generally an ardent supporter of police. I hope Captain Lydon (seen in this video) is enlightened by this post or others who are truly educated.


Get My Newsletter!

Keep up with the latest pet news with the EXCLUSIVE STEVE DALE NEWSLETTER!

So, Who is Steve Dale?


Steve Dale is a certified animal behavior specialist who has been a trusted voice in the world of pet health for over 20 years. You have likely heard him on the radio, read him in print and online, and seen him speaking at events all over the world. His contributions to advancing pet wellness have earned him many an award and recognition around the globe.

Book Credits

Learn more about the numerous books Steve has contributed to and authored!

Article Archive

Interested in reading past articles? Just use the dropdown to select a topic!



Like Us on Facebook